lists over 8,000 items under the search term "fertility"

Lords propose inclusion of donor-conception information on birth certificates

Catherine McDiarmid-Watt | Saturday, December 22, 2007 | 0 comments

An amendment to the UK's Human Tissue and Embryology Bill has been tabled in the House of Lords that will require birth certificates to indicate whether a child has been born from donor-conception. The proposal comes as parents to around 2,000 babies born using donated eggs, sperm or embryos currently have no obligation to inform their children of the nature of their birth - although anyone over the age of 18 and born through donor-conception can obtain details about their genetic parents from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA). 'We need to make it more difficult for parents to deceive their children', said Baroness Warnock, who supported the amendment. 'It is awful that children can live completely unaware of the truth.'

Some commentators have expressed reservations that if such a clause became law then it may result in even greater disruption to children born through donor-conception. Dr Simon Fishel, of the Care Fertility Unit, Nottingham, said that such children would be 'single out'. 'Birth certificates are asked for in many different walks of life. All of a sudden, it means that people will know whether someone was conceived using a donor', he said, adding, 'this has huge implications and I'm convinced there will be huge objections'. The Donor Conception Network (DCN) argued that the proposal would in fact encourage dishonesty, forcing patients to conceal their child's birth certificate should they not wish their child to know of their donor-conception origins. It highlighted that some parents choose to not inform their child until they consider them to be mature enough to properly understand the meaning of donor conception. 'Parents should be supported and not forced to tell their child,' it said.

Infertility Network UK said that although it agreed parents should be open with their children, legislation to compel this comes 'too soon'. Academic literature is unclear what the effect of being told that one or both parents are not biologically related is on children. Current surveys indicate that, in practice, most parents do inform their children if they are born from donor-conception. A 2006 study published in the journal Human Reproduction reported that 54 per cent of UK parents who had used donor sperm had opted for disclosure, which rose to 78 per cent of parents using egg donation. The DCN reported that a survey of their members revealed that 99 per cent said they would tell their child their true background.

It is not yet clear what affect the removal of donor anonymity in the UK has had on the practice of disclosing such information. The BMA opposed the removal of donor anonymity, which allows children to seek identifying information about their genetic parents once they have attained the age of 18, if they had donated since April 2005. 'Parents who are unwilling for their child to make contact with the donor may be less likely to tell their child they were donor-conceived,' said a spokesman for the BMA.

MPs will need to approve the amendment if it is to be contained in the final version of the Bill, which will go before the House of Commons sometime in the New Year. Catholic MPs will now be allowed to vote according to their conscience against the Bill, after the Government was criticised for telling Catholic Cabinet ministers that if they intended to vote against the Government Bill they would have to leave their positions. In total there are 64 Catholic MPs who are entitled to vote and the Catholic Church has already expresed its strong opposition to the Bill.


Stories of Pregnancy & Birth over 44y

- Daily blog of hope & inspiration!

4,200 Stories of Pregnancy & Birth over 44y

All the stories, divided by age, 1st pregnancy & high FSH!

"In 2005, there were more than 104,000 births in the United States to women ages 40 through 44, and over 6,500 to women 45 and older. In 2004, there were 1,786 live births to women over 42, using donor eggs."



About Catherine: I am mom to three grown sons, two grandchildren and two rescue dogs. After years of raising my boys as a single mom, I remarried a wonderful man who had never had a child of his own. Unexpectedly, I found myself pregnant at 49!
Sadly we lost that precious baby at 8 weeks, and decided to try again. Five more losses, turned down for donor egg, foster care and adoption due to my age and losses - we have accepted that there will be no more babies in our house.

Find Catherine on Google+ - Circle us on Google+ - Join us on Facebook - Follow us on Twitter


Don't just sit there, reading this story or article - say something! Do you believe it? Do you think it is impossible? Do you wish it was you? Do you have a story to share (it might get published!)

NOTE: Comments are moderated - just to stop the spambots - and so may take up to a few hours to be approved.

Catherine reserves the right to review, edit, refuse or delete any comment.

Popular Posts